The commanders of several units of the Armed Forces criticized the statement

The commanders of several units of the Armed Forces responded to the report of the 47 Magura Combat Combat Alexander Shirshin, who submitted through the “detachable tasks” – the position of the combat was criticized.

Source: Hromadske, Commander of the Magyara Birds Unit Robert Brove, 425th Separate Store “Skala”, commander 1 OSHP Dmitry “Perun” Filatov, Volunteer Formation of UDA Dmitry Yarosh and Commander of the 225th Separate Assault Regiment

Details: In particular, the commander of the Magyara Birds Unit called the statement a “public demarche” statement and condemned the form of its submission.

Advertising:

“Magura was built from a blank sheet, if I was not mistaken. It was built bright and promising. On the Orkhnaya Baptism, I also came brightly – we were witnesses for the first 48 hours, until we were overwhelmed for the first time and for the first time, I was for the first time in the first time. There are public demarches of commanders, charged with all and all? ” – wrote” Magyar “.

He added that he “did not find the Kombrig position on the network.”

“Maybe badly searched, and she is. And perhaps it is simply omitted or not being able to justify and defend her own position. In my opinion, it is not justifies that Demarsha is not published; The firebox.

The 425 separate assault regiment “Skala” was accused of “ignoring the tasks of senior management” and “Political Games”.

“The commander of the battalion of the 47th Magura Brigade Alexander Shirshin publicly refuses to obey and allows himself to be charged with command. Since he ignores the tasks of senior management, it leads to meaningless loss among personnel. It is in the message.

The Skal noted that “maybe the situation in its direction is really difficult”, but added that it was difficult for everyone.

“Instead of exposure and leadership, it suits emotional breakdowns-it looks like hysteria, not command. We work in much more dangerous areas of the front. We have repeatedly interacted with the 47th brigade-and we constantly face the mistakes of command commands. Conflicts, ” – summed up in Skal.

The commander of the 1st separate assault regiment Dmitry Filatov stated that “the real commander is not looking for the perpetrators, but arguments in argument, brings it to management and offers effective decisions”, and he called everything else “an escape and justification of his own incompetence.”

“In the war, commanders are forced to take responsibility – even in the most difficult conditions. If the commander recognizes the problem and seeks to change the situation at least within his powers, it is a commander’s act. If he simply declares” I go “and does nothing for his people, it is desertion.

The leader of the UDA Volunteer Formation Dmitry Yarosh stated that “in many respects” with a statement of a combat combat, but stressed that “a combat, mouth and platoon commanders … Very often they do not see all the problems that are on the whole of the fighting theater.”

“Therefore, I think that to publish such thoughts” on public “is to play on the hand of an eternal enemy …

At the same time, the commander of 225 of the separate assault regiment Major Oleg Shiryaev called on the Supreme Commander -in -Chief to introduce “strict restrictions” for public discussion of combat missions, the course of operations and assessment of command.

“As a military man who passed the ATO and from the first day of a full -scale war, it remains in order, it is unfortunate to observe how some of our brothers systematically depreciate the Ukrainian army under the guise of criticism of higher command. Sometimes guys puts it. It is a fact … Yes, there are tasks complicated. To make hands, to decide nothing and to spill the dirt of those who are higher.

He added that “discipline is not a formality” but a “army skeleton”.

“And finally, as an officer, I turn to the Supreme Commander: In order to preserve combat discipline and controllability – it is necessary to impose strict restrictions on public discussion of combat missions, the course of operations and assessment of command. The army is not a forum. War is not a place for personal shows,” he summed up.

Prehistory:

• The commander of the battalion of the 47th Separate Mechanized Brigade of Magura Alexander Shirshin (“Genius”) accused the command of “Defection Tasks” and the unjustified loss of people in Kurshchyna, and also wrote a report with a request to remove him from office.
• The General Staff stated that they had created a working group to study the circumstances outlined in the publication and promised to make “relevant decisions” on the results of the audit.