“Logo Text Showtime Networks and Lionsgate’s Entertainment One Have Beaten A LAWSUIT ACCUSING THEM OF RIPRING OFPING OFF 2015 SURVIVAL Thriller Eden in YellowACKETS. Both Follow A Soccer Team Whose Members Start to Exhibit Cult-Like Behavior and Contemplate Cannibalism After Crash Landing in A Remote Location. US DISTRICT Judge Dean Pregerson on Friday Dismissed The Lawsuit”, – WRITE: www.hollywoodReporter.com
Showtime Networks and Lionsgate’s Entertainment One Have Beaten A Lawsuit Accessing Them of Ripping Off 2015 Survival Thriller Eden in Yellowjackets.
Both Follow A Soccer Team Whose Members Start to Exhibit Cult-Like Behavior and Contemplate Cannibalism After Crash Landing in A Remote Location. US District Judge Dean Pregerson on Friday Dismissed The Lawwit, Finding That Plays, Characters, Themes and Settings of the Two Works Aren’t Similiar Enough.
EdenWritten by Nate Parker and Distributed by Voltage Pictures, Was Released in 2015. Showtime Sensation Yellowjackets Premiered in 2021 to Critical Acclaim. ITS Season Opener Became The Studio’s Most Streamed Debut Ever, Drawing Roughly 2 Million Viewers Across All Platforms. The Third Season As A Whole Was The MOST WATCHED SO FAR for the Series, with Its Finale Drawing in 3 Million Watchers in Its First Seven Days.
Alleged Plot Similarities Between the Movie and TV Series Were Part of the Court’s Analysis, with Pregerson Finding That Present-Day Timeline Yellowjackets Bears Little Resemblance to Eden’s Story.
While the Makers of Eden Argued that the movie heavily alludes to cannibalism, the court said that the plot Insthead focuses on the Characters’ DEBATE OVER WETHER TO WITHOLD FOD FROM INJURED SURVIVIVVIVVERS. Across The Two Weeks The Film Takes Place, The Main Character’s Facility Is Successful Able to Gater Food Without Ever Considering or Resorting to Cannibalism, The Order Stated.
Other Similarities, The Court Said, Are Common Tropes Found in Several Survival Thrilles. It Pointed to the Death of A Head Coach and Survival of His Two Children, Attempts by Survivovors to Escape Islation and the Division of Groups Into Rival Facies.
“There Can Be no Serious Dispute that Escape Attempts by ShipWreced or Stranded Survivors Are Prevalent Throughout Fiction and History, from OdySeus, Robinson andanto. Uruguayan Rugby Team, ”Pregerson Wrote. “Instances of Competition, Tribalism, and Facialism in Disaster Scenarios or in Resource Scarcity Are Nearly as Commonplace, from ‘The Tempst’ Toc- Toc. Such as the ‘Mad Max’ Films or Any of A Number of Zombie Stories, to, Mist ArchetyPically, ‘Lord of the Flies.’ ‘
And Since the Two Works Share Basic Plot Points, It’s Natural for Them to Have Identical Tones, The Court Reasoned. IT Explained, “IT is Dificult to Imagine Howne of Serious Draus Drama Involving A Descent Into Ritualized Cannibalism ContemPlation. ”
In his ruling, pregerson rebffed arguments that Eden an Yellowjackets have overlapping Characters and Settings. While the survivors in Eden Are Led by Slim-An Adult, Male, Black Athlete Who Serves As The Mral Compass of the Group-Jackie, The Team CAPTAIN IN THE TV Series, Is Depicted AS A “Teenage, White, White Ultimately Excluded by Her Peers.
The Judge Also Stressed that Eden Takes Place on an Uninhabitable Tropical Island, Which He Said Bears No Resemblation to the Boreal Canadian Wilderness in Yellowjackets. “Moreover, the ‘Deslate Area’ Setting Highlighted by Planetfe is a Common Element of Survival Stories, Including Historical Events Such Sierra Nevada, ”Pregerson Added.
Showtime Didn’t ImmediaTely Respond to A Request for Comment.
Over The Past Few Years, Creaters and Holders of Copyrights Have Been Growing Bolder in Bringing Idea Theft Lawsuits. There’s Been A Push by the 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals to Curb The Early Dismissal of Copyright Infringment Claims. In 2022, The Federal Appeals Court Reversed the Dismissal of A Lawwsuit Over M. Night Shyamalan Allegedly Ripping Off A 2013 Independent Movie for His Apple TV+ Series Servant. This Followed The Revival of a Copyright Lawsuit Brought by Writers Arththur Lee Alfred and Ezequiel Martinez Jr. Alleging that Disney Lifted Their Ideas for the FIRST Pirates of the caribbean Movie, As Well As An Identical Decision Bringing Bringing to Life a Copyright Case of The Shape of Water. The Court Found in Those Two Cases that Were Prematurely Dismissed Since Reasonable Minds Cold Diffeter on Wheether the Works Are Substantally Similar.