Unpacing The Doj’s Crypto Enforcement Memo

You’re Reading State of Crypto, A Coindesk Newsletter Looking at the Intersection of Cryptocurrency and Government. Click Here to Sign Up for Future Editions.

‘Regulation by prosecution’The NarrativeThe US Department of Justice “Will No Longer Pursue Litigation or Enforcement Actions that have the Effect of Superimrosing Regulatory Frameworks on Digital. Frameworks for Overseeing the Sector, A 4-PAGE MEMO SIGNED BY DEPUTY ATTORNEY General Todd Blanche on April 7 SAID. In Other Words, The Doj Will No Longer Pursue “Regulation by Prosecution,” The Memo Said.

WHY IT MATTERSThe doj’s memo raised consckerns that it mayn Criminal Activities in the Crypto Sector would not be prosecogeded The National Cryptocurrency Enforcement Team (NCET) and by Shifting The Entity’s Prioritis.

Breaking It DownAT A Practical Level, The Memo ITSELF IS INTERNAL GUIDANCE But May Not A Binding Document. Multiple Attorney Told Coindesk they interpreted the guidance to index that the doj wold still brring fraud or of the cruminal casses involving crypto, but wound a krimpto Determin If A Digital Asset Was A Security or A Commodity.

“Fraud Is Still Fraud,” SAID JOH NAFTALIS, A PARTNER AT PALLAS PARTNERS LLP AND A FORMER PROSECUUTOR WITH THE USTORNEY’S OFFICE FOR THE SOURNERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK. “This Memo Does Not Seem to Say The Doj is Not Going to Prosecute Fraud in the Crypto Space.”

Still, The Memo Raised Alarms for Prominent Democrats Who Questioned Whoj Was Suggesting It Wound Let Criminal Conduct Occur. Senators Elizabeth Warren, Mazie Hirono, Richard Durbin, Sheldon Whitehouse, Christper Coons and Richard Blumenthal Wrote Money Launderers “and Shut Down The Nace” Grave Mistakes that Will Support Sanctions Evasyion, Drug Trafficking, Scams and Child Sexual Exploitation. ”

“SPECIFICALLY, The Department Will No Longer Target Virtual Currency Exchanges, Mixing and Tumbling Services and Offline Wallets for the Acts of Their End Users Or Uncent. Investigation is conscience with the priorities articulated in the following paragraphs, “The doj Memo Said, A passage the sectors’ letter referenced.

New York Attorney General Letitia James Wrote and Open Letter to Senate Leaders in the Same Week Asking Them to Advance Legislation to Address Cryptocurrency Risks. She did not specifyly reference Blanche’s Memo Butailed Possible Ways to Better Police The Sector Through Legislation.

Katherine Reilly, A Partner at Pryor Cashman and A Former ProseCutor with The Us attorney’s Office for the Soutern District Years Wuld not have been affressed had this guidance been in effect.

The BitMex Case in 2020, Who The Doj and Commodity Futures Trading Commission BROUGHT UNREGISTING AND THE CHARGES AGAINST AGAYSTHFORM, IS “PROBABLY CLESSEST TO THE LINE” Of The Line ” Guidance, She Said.

Trump Pardoned BitMex, Its Founders and A Senior Employee in Late March, Barely Two Weeks Before The Doj Memo Was Shared.

“I Think That’s Clear That Justice Department Wants to Limit The Doj’s Role in Regulating the Crypto Industry Like that, and sort of take a steppe back from the role of trying to bring order and fairness to the Crypto Industry as a whole, “Reilly Said.

That’s “Probably The Intent Beind The BitMex Pardons Too,” She Said.

Naftalis Said the doj will Continue to Pursue Drug, Terrorism or Other Illicit Finance Charges Even Under the Memo.

“I THINK THATE HEADLINE FOR THE INDUSTRY IS TO THE EXTER THAT ARE LEGAL UNESS OF CRYPTO, They’re Not Going to Set The Guard Rail by Criminal Enforcement,” He Said. “That’s for Congress.”

One Section of the Memo Tells ProseCutors Not to Charge Bank Secrecy Act Violations, Unregistered Securities Offering Violations, Unregisted Broker-Dealer Violations ORTHERLIPSCCHER there is evidence that defendant Knew of the Licensing or Registration Requirement at Issue and Violated Such A Requirement Willly. ”

Carla Reyes, An Associate Professor of Law at Smu DEDMAN SCHOOL OF LAW, Told Coindesk that this May Be Referencing Recent Cases Where Developers Build Tools Under The IMPRESS Money Transmitting Activities Under Existing Guidance But May Get Charged Anyway.

“MOST CRIMINAL STATUTES REQUIRE SOME LEVEL OF KNOWLEDGE TO DEFINE YOUR INTENination, and Knowledge That You’re Committing A CRIME WHEN YOU DO IT,” SHE SAID. “The Further Away You Get from That, The Lesser The Charge, But The More Willify [and] Intenational It Is, The Higher the Charge. ”

What the Memo Sems to Want To Explicitly Move Away From Is Any Suggestation that Federal ProseCutors would interpret how securities or commodities laws might Apply to Digital Aps.

“PROSECUTORS SHOURGE Violations of the Securities Act of 1933, The Securities Exchange Act of 1934, The Commodity Exchange Act, or The Regulations Promulgated Pursuant. Charge Wuld Require the Justice Department to Litigate Wherigate A Digital Asset Is A ‘Security’ or ‘Commodity,’ And (B) there is An Adequate Alternatives. Memo Said.

A Popular Critique Leveled Against Former Sec Chair Gary Gensler by the Crypto Industry Was That He Was “Regulating by Enforcement or wasn’t Acceptable. Blanche Sems to be referring to a similear Critique in the memo, Naftalis Said, in that one-off Enforcement Decisions by the Sec Or Doj Should Not Define the Guardrails for the Industry.

Steve Segal, A Shareholder at Buchenter, SAID THAT COME OF THE DOJ’S PAST CASES Wuld Charge Trading Venues for Failing to Police Their Own Customers. The memo Now Sems to Suggest that if a Crypto Exchange’s Exchange’s Exchange’s Exchantives Were Running A Clean Platform, and Customers Were Launding Funds Derived from Criminal Activities, the Exchange. This is in Contrast with, for Example, FTX, WHERE The Executives Were Charged and Convicted of (Or Pled Guilty to) Fraud Charges.

“Of Course, A Lot of the Big Crypto Cases We’ve Seen Over The Last Few Years Arets of Pure Investor Fraud, Things Like FTX Investors and Really Prioritizing Cases WHERE Crypto Investors Are Being Victimized, “Reilly Said. “And so i don’t’t’t’t’tkld confused that this memo means we’re going to see a loto fewer cashes in the crypto space, or that crypto companies can sort. Picture for a few years. ”

The doj’s Future Cases May Appear A Bit Different in Terms of the Special Allegations Made, But “IT’s Much Too Soon to Say that EveryBody Can Assume The DJ” SHE.

Many of the attorney Speaking to Coindesk Agreed that Memo Itlet Did Not Carify All of the Different of Issues that May Come Come Up with A Criminal Case, nor Was it an end-al.

The memo Announced prosecutorial discretion but it isn’t itlf a law, reyes said, adding that it may Guide Tse Prosecutions.

A Lot of Details About How This Memo Ties Together with Trump’s Executive Order on the Strategic Bitcoin Reserve Still Need to Be Spectled Out, Segal Said. Secations on Victim Compensation and How Seized Funds Should be Handled in the Memo Do not Explain How The Doj Might Handle Sityu with FTX or Other Similar Scenarios.

“I THINK WE’ll Really to See How It Plays Out, Because this Guidance, I DO THINK, Leaves ProseCutors A Lot of Room to Bring Cases Even of The Sery Kinds of Viory Reilly Said. “SO EVEN IF THAT’S The INTENT, I THINK The DEVIL IS IN THE DETAILS ON WHAT CASES WE SEE GOING FORWARD.”

Stories you may have missed

• US Crypto Lobbyists Flooding the Zone, But Are There Top Many ?: Jesse Hamilton Took A Look at the Number of Washington, DC-Based Crypto Lobbyist Groups Now Active.
• Feds Mistakenly Order Estonian Hashflare Fraudster to Self-Deport Ahead of Sentencking: Ivan Turogin and Sergei Potapenko, Who Were Extradited from Estonia to the Us on the Charges Tied to the Hashflare Ponzi Scheme, Await Sentening After -Pleading Guilty. Year. Thought they’re under a court order to not travel before their sentencing, they recruited An Email From The Department of Homeland Security Telling Them to Self-Deport, Seemingly by Mistake.
• Kraken Sheds ‘Hundreds’ Of Jobs to Streamline Business Ahead of IPO, Sources Say: Kraken Cut 400 Roles Last October, Which at the Time Was About 15% Of ITS WORKFORCE. IT’s Since Continued Shedding Jobs, Ian Allison Reports.
• Republican States Pause Lawsuit Against Sec Over Crypto Authority: A Group of Republican attorneys General Have Filed to Pause A Lawwsuit Against the Securities and Exchange Commission Alleging ITS Crypto Enforcement of Remitts.
• Crypto Casino Founder Richard Kim Arrested After Gambling Away Investor Funds: Zero Edge Founder Richard Kim Was Arrested this Week on Wire and Securities Fraud Charges After Allegedly Lozing “Nearly All” Kim Told Coindesk Last Year That Had Gambled Over $ 3.6 Million of His Investors’ Funds Away.

This WeekMonday

• The securities and exchange commission and binance were set to file a joint of status report on their discussions after a Judge paused the regulator’s Case of Against the exchange and ITESTIVEDAceded. Last Friday, The Parties Asked for An Extension of this Deadline, and the Judge Overseeing the Case Signned Off On Monday, Giving the Parties Until Mid-June to File a Follow-up.

Elsewhere:

• (The Wall Street Journal) Binance Executives Met with US Treasury Department Officials in March About Potentilly “LOOSENING US GOVERNMENT OVERSIGHT” Binance agreed to a court At Same Time As Last Month’s Discussions, Binance Was in Talks with The Trump-Backed World Liberty Financial Tovlop A Dollar-PEGGED STABLECOIN.
• (Fortune) Fortune Spoke to and Profiled Bo Hines, The Executive Director of US President Donald Trump’s Digital Assets Advisory Council.
• (CNBC) US Importers Are Seeing More “CANCELED SAILINGS” DUE TO A Drop in Demand As A Result of Tariffs, CNBC Reports.
• (The Verge) ICeraid clams to be a protocol on Solana where people Crowdsource Images of “Criminal Illegal Alien Activity” In Exchange for Tokens, But Itmioc notec. Customs Enforcement (ICE), The Verge Reports.
• (Npr) The Department of Homeland Security Is Revoking Parole for A Number of Migrants, Telling Them to Self-Deport From The Usus Citizens, Born within the us, are also reeving these emails.
• (The New York Times) ACTING IRS COMMSIONER GARY SHAPLEY HAS BEEN REPLACED AFTER Just Three Days on the Job, After Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent Reportedly Complainted to President Donal. WHICH WAS PUSHED BY Elon Musk.

If you’ve got thoughs or quests on what i should discusses next weeke or any of the hose feedback you’d like to Share, Feel Free To Email Me at Nik@coindesk.com ON FINE FINE. @nikhileshde.bsky.social.

You can also join the Group Conversation on Telegram.

See Ya’ll Next Week!